Problem 1
A manufacturing firm evaluates three strategic capacity expansion alternatives (Small Plant, Medium Plant, Large Plant) to meet uncertain 5-year demand for a new electric vehicle powertrain component. Market analysis identifies three discrete economic states of nature with estimated probabilities: - Low Demand: P(S1) = 0.20 - Medium Demand: P(S2) = 0.50 - High Demand: P(S3) = 0.30 Payoff matrix (net present values in USD): - Small Plant: S1 = USD 120,000; S2 = USD 180,000; S3 = USD 180,000 - Medium Plant: S1 = USD 80,000; S2 = USD 240,000; S3 = USD 260,000 - Large Plant: S1 = -USD 45,000 (Loss); S2 = USD 260,000; S3 = USD 350,000 Calculate the Expected Monetary Value (EMV) for the optimal decision alternative and determine the Expected Value of Perfect Information (EVPI).
- AExpected monetary value is USD 168,000 (Expected value of perfect information EVPI = USD 91,000)
- BExpected monetary value is USD 214,000 (Expected value of perfect information EVPI = USD 45,000)
- CExpected monetary value is USD 240,000 (Expected value of perfect information EVPI = USD 19,000)
- DExpected monetary value is USD 226,000 (Expected value of perfect information EVPI = USD 33,000)correct
Show the solution
**Step 1: Calculate Expected Monetary Value ($EMV$) for Each Decision Alternative** - **Small Plant:** $$EMV_{Small} = 0.20(120{,}000) + 0.50(180{,}000) + 0.30(180{,}000)$$ $$EMV_{Small} = 24{,}000 + 90{,}000 + 54{,}000 = \text{USD } 168{,}000$$ - **Medium Plant:** $$EMV_{Medium} = 0.20(80{,}000) + 0.50(240{,}000) + 0.30(260{,}000)$$ $$EMV_{Medium} = 16{,}000 + 120{,}000 + 78{,}000 = \text{USD } 214{,}000$$ - **Large Plant:** $$EMV_{Large} = 0.20(-45{,}000) + 0.50(260{,}000) + 0.30(350{,}000)$$ $$EMV_{Large} = -9{,}000 + 130{,}000 + 105{,}000 = \text{USD } 226{,}000$$ The optimal decision under expected value is **Large Plant** with $EMV^* = \text{USD } 226{,}000$. **Step 2: Calculate Expected Value with Perfect Information ($EVwPI$)** If perfect information could foresee the exact state of nature: - If Low Demand ($P = 0.20$): Choose Small Plant $\implies \text{Payoff } = \text{USD } 120{,}000$ - If Medium Demand ($P = 0.50$): Choose Large Plant $\implies \text{Payoff } = \text{USD } 260{,}000$ - If High Demand ($P = 0.30$): Choose Large Plant $\implies \text{Payoff } = \text{USD } 350{,}000$ $$EVwPI = 0.20(120{,}000) + 0.50(260{,}000) + 0.30(350{,}000)$$ $$EVwPI = 24{,}000 + 130{,}000 + 105{,}000 = \text{USD } 259{,}000$$ **Step 3: Calculate Expected Value of Perfect Information ($EVPI$)** $$EVPI = EVwPI - \max(EMV) = 259{,}000 - 226{,}000 = \text{USD } 33{,}000$$ The maximum expected monetary value is **USD 226,000** and the firm should pay no more than **USD 33,000** for perfect market research.
Problem 2
An engineering project manager performs Earned Value Management (EVM) for a capital plant upgrade at Month 6 of a 12-month schedule. The total authorized Budget at Completion is BAC = 1,000,000 USD. At the review date, the project control metrics are: • Planned Value (PV) = 450,000 USD • Earned Value (EV) = 380,000 USD • Actual Cost (AC) = 420,000 USD Calculate the Cost Performance Index (CPI) and the projected Estimate at Completion (EAC), assuming the project will continue to perform at its current cost efficiency rate.
- A1.105 CPI and Estimate at Completion EAC = 905,000 USD (Under budget and ahead of schedule)
- B0.844 CPI and Estimate at Completion EAC = 1,185,000 USD (Lagging schedule performance)
- C0.905 CPI and Estimate at Completion EAC = 1,105,000 USD (Over budget and behind schedule)correct
- D0.950 CPI and Estimate at Completion EAC = 1,050,000 USD (Within acceptable contingency margin)
Show the solution
**Step 1: Compute Cost and Schedule Variances** From the FE Reference Handbook (Engineering Management / Earned Value Analysis): - Cost Variance: $$\text{CV} = \text{EV} - \text{AC} = 380\text{ USD}{,}000 - 420\text{ USD}{,}000 = -40\text{ USD}{,}000 \quad (\text{over budget})$$ - Schedule Variance: $$\text{SV} = \text{EV} - \text{PV} = 380\text{ USD}{,}000 - 450\text{ USD}{,}000 = -70\text{ USD}{,}000 \quad (\text{behind schedule})$$ **Step 2: Calculate Performance Indices (CPI and SPI)** - Cost Performance Index: $$\text{CPI} = \frac{\text{EV}}{\text{AC}} = \frac{380\text{ USD}{,}000}{420\text{ USD}{,}000} = 0.90476 \approx 0.905$$ (For every dollar spent, only 0.905 USD of planned work is delivered). - Schedule Performance Index: $$\text{SPI} = \frac{\text{EV}}{\text{PV}} = \frac{380\text{ USD}{,}000}{450\text{ USD}{,}000} = 0.8444 \approx 0.844$$ **Step 3: Calculate Estimate at Completion (EAC)** Assuming future cost performance continues at the established cumulative $\text{CPI}$: $$\text{EAC} = \frac{\text{BAC}}{\text{CPI}} = \frac{1\text{ USD}{,}000{,}000}{0.90476} = 1\text{ USD}{,}105{,}263 \approx 1\text{ USD}{,}105{,}000$$ Conclusion: The metrics are **0.905 CPI and Estimate at Completion EAC = 1,105,000 USD** (Option C).
Problem 3
Continuous quality improvement and total quality management frameworks guide industrial engineering practice. Select the THREE statements that correctly characterize Deming PDCA (Plan-Do-Check-Act) and ISO 9001 quality management principles.
- AIn the "Plan" phase, the engineering team establishes baseline performance metrics, investigates root causes of process defects, and designs a targeted operational change.
- BIn the "Check" phase, pilot performance data are analyzed against baseline objectives to verify whether process improvements achieved predicted statistical significance.
- CISO 9001 incorporates a risk-based thinking framework that systematically identifies and mitigates risks across process interactions before execution.
- DIn the "Act" phase, all pilot modifications are completely undone regardless of results to preserve initial operating procedures.
Show the solution
**Step 1: Review PDCA Quality Management Framework** 1. **Plan:** Identify problem, map process, analyze root causes (Ishikawa, Pareto), and formulate a measurable intervention plan. Statement A is correct. 2. **Do:** Execute the plan on a controlled pilot or small-scale basis. 3. **Check (Study):** Measure pilot outcomes, analyze key performance metrics, and compare against goals. Statement B is correct. 4. **Act:** Standardize successful modifications into standard operating procedures (SOPs) or iterate if goals were unmet. 5. **ISO 9001:** Emphasizes customer satisfaction, process approach, and risk-based thinking. Statement C is correct. **Step 2: Distractor Analysis** - Statement D is false: Successful pilot improvements are standardized into official work instructions, not discarded. Correct choices: **A, B, and C**.