An industrial facility operates a continuously running ventilation fan driven by a three-phase electric motor drawing $60.0\text{ kW}$ average electric power for $4{,}000\text{ hours/year}$. Electricity costs 0.150 USD/kWh. Plant engineering evaluates retrofitting the motor with a Variable Frequency Drive (VFD). The turnkey VFD installation costs 12{,}000 USD and reduces motor power consumption by $25.0\%$. Ongoing annual VFD maintenance is 800 USD/year. The VFD has a useful life of $6\text{ years}$ with zero salvage value. The company's Minimum Attractive Rate of Return (MARR) is $8.0\%\text{ per year}$. Calculate the Equivalent Uniform Annual Worth (AW) of the net savings provided by this VFD retrofit, in dollars per year (USD/year).
Show the solution
**Step 1: Calculate Gross Annual Energy Cost Savings** From the FE Reference Handbook (Engineering Economics / Annual Worth Analysis): Base annual energy consumption: $$E_{base} = 60.0\text{ kW} \times 4{,}000\text{ h/year} = 240{,}000\text{ kWh/year}$$ Annual energy savings (25% reduction): $$\Delta E = 0.25 \times 240{,}000\text{ kWh} = 60{,}000\text{ kWh/year}$$ Gross annual energy savings in dollars: $$S_{energy} = 60{,}000\text{ kWh/yr} \times 0.150\text{ USD/kWh} = 9{,}000\text{ USD/year}$$ **Step 2: Determine Net Annual Operating Benefit** Subtracting annual VFD maintenance: $$A_{net} = S_{energy} - C_{maint} = 9{,}000\text{ USD} - 800\text{ USD} = 8{,}200\text{ USD/year}$$ **Step 3: Annualize Capital Investment Cost (Capital Recovery)** The initial capital expenditure is $P = 12{,}000\text{ USD}$, with $N = 6\text{ years}$ and $i = 8.0\%$ ($0.08$): $$CR = P(A/P, i, N) = P \left[ \frac{i(1 + i)^N}{(1 + i)^N - 1} \right]$$ $$(1 + 0.08)^6 = (1.08)^6 = 1.586874$$ $$(A/P, 8\%, 6) = \frac{0.08 \times 1.586874}{1.586874 - 1} = \frac{0.126950}{0.586874} = 0.216315$$ Annual capital recovery cost: $$CR = 12{,}000\text{ USD} \times 0.216315 = 2{,}595.78\text{ USD/year}$$ **Step 4: Compute Net Equivalent Annual Worth (AW)** $$AW = A_{net} - CR = 8{,}200\text{ USD} - 2{,}595.78\text{ USD} = 5{,}604.22\text{ USD/year} \approx 5{,}604\text{ USD/year}$$ Conclusion: The net annual worth of savings is **5,604 USD/year**.