Problem 1
An industrial energy efficiency upgrade requires an initial capital expenditure of $P = \$180{,}000$ and provides uniform net annual energy cost savings of $A = \$45{,}000/\text{year}$ at the end of each year for $n = 6\text{ years}$, with negligible terminal salvage value. The corporate Minimum Attractive Rate of Return (MARR) is $10.0\%$. Using linear interpolation between standard interest rates: What is the internal rate of return (IRR) of the upgrade, and is the investment economically justified?
- A10.0% (equal to MARR baseline)
- B8.5% (below MARR error)
- C15.5% (overestimated return)
- D13.0% (with PW(12%) = +$5,013 and PW(14%) = -$5,008, economically justified since IRR > MARR)correct
Show the solution
**Step 1: Formulate Present Worth Equation for IRR** From the FE Reference Handbook (Engineering Economics / Rate of Return / Internal Rate of Return): The Internal Rate of Return $i^*$ is the discount rate that drives net present worth to zero: $$PW(i^*) = -P + A (P/A, i^*, n) = 0$$ $$-180{,}000 + 45{,}000 (P/A, i^*, 6) = 0 \implies (P/A, i^*, 6) = \frac{180{,}000}{45{,}000} = 4.000$$ **Step 2: Bracket IRR with Trial Interest Rates** Recall $(P/A, i, n) = \frac{(1+i)^n - 1}{i(1+i)^n}$: - At $i_1 = 12.0\%$: $$(P/A, 12\%, 6) = \frac{(1.12)^6 - 1}{0.12(1.12)^6} = \frac{1.973823 - 1}{0.12(1.973823)} = 4.111407$$ $$PW(12\%) = -180{,}000 + 45{,}000(4.111407) = -180{,}000 + 185{,}013 = +\$5{,}013$$ - At $i_2 = 14.0\%$: $$(P/A, 14\%, 6) = \frac{(1.14)^6 - 1}{0.14(1.14)^6} = \frac{2.194973 - 1}{0.14(2.194973)} = 3.888668$$ $$PW(14\%) = -180{,}000 + 45{,}000(3.888668) = -180{,}000 + 174{,}990 = -\$5{,}010$$ **Step 3: Interpolate for Exact IRR** $$i^* \approx 12.0\% + (14.0\% - 12.0\%) \times \frac{5{,}013 - 0}{5{,}013 - (-5{,}010)} = 12.0\% + 2.0\% \left(\frac{5{,}013}{10{,}023}\right) = 12.0\% + 2.0\%(0.50015) = 13.00\%$$ Since $\text{IRR} = 13.0\% > \text{MARR} = 10.0\%$, the project is economically attractive. Conclusion: The internal rate of return is **$13.0\%$**, which is economically justified.
Problem 2
A municipal public works department evaluates three mutually exclusive storm drainage pumping station designs for a regional watershed protection project. All designs have a useful service life of 20 years with zero salvage value ($S = 0$). The MARR is $i = 6.0\%$ per year ($(\text{A/P}, 6\%, 20) = 0.087184$). Economic data for the alternatives: - Alternative 1: Initial Cost $P_1 = \$1{,}200{,}000$, Annual O&M $C_1 = \$30{,}000$, Annual Flood Damage Reduction Benefit $B_1 = \$180{,}000$ - Alternative 2: Initial Cost $P_2 = \$1{,}800{,}000$, Annual O&M $C_2 = \$45{,}000$, Annual Flood Damage Reduction Benefit $B_2 = \$265{,}000$ - Alternative 3: Initial Cost $P_3 = \$2{,}500{,}000$, Annual O&M $C_3 = \$65{,}000$, Annual Flood Damage Reduction Benefit $B_3 = \$320{,}000$ Using incremental Benefit-Cost ratio analysis ($\Delta B / \Delta C$), which alternative is the economically preferred design?
- A1.34 (incremental ratio B/C of Alternative 1 vs Do-Nothing)
- B1.15 (incremental ratio B/C of Alternative 3 vs Do-Nothing)
- C0.85 (Do-Nothing selection threshold)
- D1.26 (incremental ratio ΔB/ΔC for Alternative 2 vs Alternative 1; preferred selection)correct
Show the solution
Step 1: Compute annual equivalent capital recovery and total annual cost for each design: $$(\text{A/P}, 6\%, 20) = \frac{0.06(1 + 0.06)^{20}}{(1 + 0.06)^{20} - 1} = 0.087184$$ - Alternative 1: $$\text{EUAC}_1 = \$1{,}200{,}000(0.087184) + \$30{,}000 = \$104{,}621 + \$30{,}000 = \$134{,}621$$ $$B_1 / C_1 = \frac{\$180{,}000}{\$134{,}621} = 1.337 > 1.0 \implies \text{Alternative 1 is economically viable (Defender)}$$ Step 2: Incremental analysis of Alternative 2 vs Alternative 1: $$\Delta P = \$1{,}800{,}000 - \$1{,}200{,}000 = \$600{,}000$$ $$\Delta C = \$600{,}000(0.087184) + (\$45{,}000 - \$30{,}000) = \$52{,}310 + \$15{,}000 = \$67{,}310$$ $$\Delta B = \$265{,}000 - \$180{,}000 = \$85{,}000$$ $$\frac{\Delta B}{\Delta C} = \frac{\$85{,}000}{\$67{,}310} = 1.263 > 1.0$$ Since $\Delta B / \Delta C > 1.0$, the additional investment in Alternative 2 is justified. Alternative 2 becomes the new Defender. Step 3: Incremental analysis of Alternative 3 vs Alternative 2: $$\Delta P = \$2{,}500{,}000 - \$1{,}800{,}000 = \$700{,}000$$ $$\Delta C = \$700{,}000(0.087184) + (\$65{,}000 - \$45{,}000) = \$61{,}029 + \$20{,}000 = \$81{,}029$$ $$\Delta B = \$320{,}000 - \$265{,}000 = \$55{,}000$$ $$\frac{\Delta B}{\Delta C} = \frac{\$55{,}000}{\$81{,}029} = 0.6787 < 1.0$$ Since $\Delta B / \Delta C < 1.0$, Alternative 3 fails the incremental benefit test and is rejected. Therefore, Alternative 2 is the preferred selection (option D).
Problem 3
A regional municipal public works authority is evaluating a public flood mitigation diversion canal project with a useful life of N = 20 years and an effective annual discount rate of i = 6.0%: - Initial capital construction cost: P = $8,000,000 - Annual routine inspection and levee maintenance: C_ann = $120,000 per year - Annual direct public flood damage reduction benefits: B_ann = $950,000 per year - Estimated terminal salvage value of land and right-of-way at year 20: S = $1,500,000 What is the conventional Benefit-Cost ratio (B/C) of this public infrastructure project?
- A1.05
- B1.42
- C1.11
- D1.22correct
Show the solution
Step 1 - Compound Interest Factors for $i = 6.0\%$, $N = 20\text{ years}$: $$(1 + i)^N = (1.06)^{20} = 3.207135$$ - Capital Recovery factor $(A/P, 6\%, 20)$: $$(A/P, 6\%, 20) = \frac{i(1 + i)^N}{(1 + i)^N - 1} = \frac{0.06(3.207135)}{2.207135} = \frac{0.192428}{2.207135} = 0.087184$$ - Sinking Fund factor $(A/F, 6\%, 20)$: $$(A/F, 6\%, 20) = \frac{i}{(1 + i)^N - 1} = \frac{0.06}{2.207135} = 0.027184$$ Step 2 - Equivalent Uniform Annual Cost of Capital Recovery ($CR$): $$CR = P (A/P, 6\%, 20) - S (A/F, 6\%, 20)$$ $$P (A/P) = \$8,000,000 \times 0.087184 = \$697,472/\text{year}$$ $$S (A/F) = \$1,500,000 \times 0.027184 = \$40,776/\text{year}$$ $$CR = \$697,472 - \$40,776 = \$656,696/\text{year}$$ Step 3 - Total Equivalent Uniform Annual Cost ($C_{\text{total}}$): $$C_{\text{total}} = CR + C_{\text{ann}} = \$656,696 + \$120,000 = \$776,696/\text{year}$$ Step 4 - Calculate Conventional Benefit-Cost Ratio: $$B/C = \frac{B_{\text{ann}}}{C_{\text{total}}} = \frac{\$950,000/\text{year}}{\$776,696/\text{year}} = 1.2231 \approx 1.22$$ Because $B/C > 1.0$, the public infrastructure project is economically justified. The B/C ratio is 1.22 (Option D).