Two mutually exclusive alternatives are under consideration, each with a 6-year life and a MARR of 10%. Alternative A costs $50,000 and generates $12,000/year in benefits. Alternative B costs $80,000 and generates $17,500/year in benefits. Based on present worth analysis, which alternative should be selected?
- AAlternative A, since PW A = +$2,263 while PW B = −$3,783correct
- BAlternative B, since it has the larger annual benefit
- CAlternative B, since it has the larger initial investment and therefore larger scale
- DNeither — both alternatives should be rejected because PW B is negative
Show the solution
Compute the present worth of each alternative separately and compare. (P/A, 10%, 6) = [1 − (1.10) −6 ]/0.10 = 4.3553. PW A = −50,000 + 12,000(4.3553) = −50,000 + 52,263 = +$2,263. PW B = −80,000 + 17,500(4.3553) = −80,000 + 76,217 = −$3,783. Since the alternatives are mutually exclusive, the decision rule is to pick the one with the higher present worth among those with PW ≥ 0 (do-nothing is always an option). A has a positive PW; B does not. (B) and (C) are both distractors based on raw size (benefit or investment) rather than the actual time-value-of-money comparison, which is exactly the trap this kind of problem is designed to catch: a bigger alternative is not automatically the better economic choice. (D) is wrong because A should not be rejected; only B underperforms the MARR here.