Problem 1
An environmental engineering firm is preparing an economic evaluation comparing alternative air pollution scrubbers with different capital costs, operating requirements, and design lifespans. Match each economic analysis term to its correct definition or role in environmental technology selection.
Show the solution
Comparing environmental engineering equipment alternatives requires life-cycle cost analysis because technologies frequently trade off high initial capital expenditure (CAPEX) against lower recurring operating and maintenance expense (OPEX), or vice versa. The Capital Recovery Factor $(A/P, i, n) = \dfrac{i(1+i)^n}{(1+i)^n - 1}$ annualizes upfront capital costs at interest rate $i$ over life $n$. Equivalent Uniform Annual Cost (EUAC) sums this annualized capital payment with annual O&M costs ($EUAC = P(A/P, i, n) + O\&M$), enabling a fair apples-to-apples comparison between devices with different useful lifespans (e.g., a 10-year wet scrubber vs. a 20-year electrostatic precipitator). When evaluating higher-efficiency upgrades, incremental analysis ($\Delta B / \Delta C > 1.0$) ensures that the incremental environmental improvement justifies the added expenditure over a compliant baseline system.
Problem 2
A chemical manufacturing facility is required by state environmental regulators to install a Volatile Organic Compound (VOC) abatement system. Two mutually exclusive compliant engineering technologies are under evaluation over a 10-year planning horizon with negligible salvage value (n = 10 years): - Option A (Regenerative Thermal Oxidizer - RTO): Initial capital investment PA = $320,000; annual operation and maintenance (O&M) cost AA = $45,000/year. - Option B (Engineered Biofilter with Humidification): Initial capital investment PB = $480,000; annual operation and maintenance (O&M) cost AB = $18,000/year. If the facility’s Minimum Attractive Rate of Return (MARR) is 8.0%, determine the incremental rate of return (ΔIRR) on the additional investment required for Option B and specify which system should be selected.
- AΔIRR = 7.2%; select Option A because the incremental investment fails to meet MARR
- BΔIRR = 14.5%; select Option B based on gross annual operational savings
- CΔIRR = 10.9%; select Option B because the incremental rate of return exceeds the MARRcorrect
- DΔIRR = 8.5%; select Option A because the incremental return margin is negligible
Show the solution
1. INCREMENTAL CASH FLOW (OPTION B - OPTION A): Incremental initial capital: $$\Delta P = P_B - P_A = \$480{,}000 - \$320{,}000 = \$160{,}000$$ Incremental annual operational savings: $$\Delta A = A_A - A_B = \$45{,}000 - \$18{,}000 = \$27{,}000/\text{year}$$ 2. PRESENT WORTH EQUATION: Equating present worth of savings to incremental capital: $$(P/A, \Delta \text{IRR}, 10) = \frac{\Delta P}{\Delta A} = \frac{\$160{,}000}{\$27{,}000} = 5.9259$$ 3. SOLVING FOR ΔIRR: Using $(P/A, i, 10) = \frac{1 - (1+i)^{-10}}{i}$: - At $i = 10\%$: $(P/A, 10\%, 10) = 6.1446$ - At $i = 11\%$: $(P/A, 11\%, 10) = 5.8893$ Interpolating: $$\Delta \text{IRR} \approx 10\% + 1\% \times \left( \frac{6.1446 - 5.9259}{6.1446 - 5.8893} \right) = 10\% + \frac{0.2187}{0.2553}\% = 10.86\% \approx 10.9\%$$ 4. ECONOMIC DECISION CRITERION: $$\Delta \text{IRR} = 10.9\% > \text{MARR} = 8.0\%$$ Because the incremental rate of return exceeds the MARR, the extra $160,000 investment is justified. Therefore, **Option B** is chosen. DISTRACTOR RATIONALE: - Option A (7.2%) calculates simple payback ($160/27 = 5.92$ yrs) without compounding. - Option B (14.5%) divides savings by base project investment alone. - Option D (8.5%) uses an inaccurate linear approximation.
Problem 3
An industrial manufacturing facility evaluates installing a closed-loop zero-liquid discharge (ZLD) wastewater recovery unit. The initial capital investment is P = 850,000 USD (850 k USD). The system generates net annual operating cost savings (fresh water purchases avoided, sewer surcharges eliminated, minus power and chemical costs) of A = 185,000 USD/year (185 k USD/yr) over an economic service life of N = 8 years. At the end of Year 8, equipment salvage value is S = 90,000 USD (90 k USD). If the facility's Minimum Attractive Rate of Return (MARR) is i = 9.0% compounded annually, calculate the Net Present Value (NPV) of the project in thousands of dollars (k USD). Record your answer to one decimal place.
Show the solution
**Step 1: Identify cash flows and economic parameters** - Initial capital expenditure at $t = 0$: $P = -\$850\text{ k}$ - Uniform annual net savings for $t = 1$ to $8$: $A = +\$185\text{ k/year}$ - Salvage value at $t = 8$: $S = +\$90\text{ k}$ - Discount rate: $i = 9.0\% = 0.09$ - Time horizon: $N = 8\text{ years}$ **Step 2: Calculate compound interest factors** Uniform Series Present Worth factor $(P/A, i, N)$: $$(P/A, 9\%, 8) = \frac{(1 + i)^N - 1}{i (1 + i)^N} = \frac{(1.09)^8 - 1}{0.09 \times (1.09)^8}$$ $$(1.09)^8 = 1.992563$$ $$(P/A, 9\%, 8) = \frac{1.992563 - 1}{0.09 \times 1.992563} = \frac{0.992563}{0.179331} = 5.53482$$ Single Payment Present Worth factor $(P/F, i, N)$: $$(P/F, 9\%, 8) = (1 + i)^{-N} = (1.09)^{-8} = \frac{1}{1.992563} = 0.501866$$ **Step 3: Compute Net Present Value ($NPV$)** $$NPV = -P + A \times (P/A, 9\%, 8) + S \times (P/F, 9\%, 8)$$ $$NPV = -850.0 + 185.0 \times (5.53482) + 90.0 \times (0.501866)$$ $$NPV = -850.0 + 1{,}023.942 + 45.168 = -850.0 + 1{,}069.110 = +219.11\text{ \text{ k USD}} \approx 219.1\text{ \text{ k USD}}$$ Since $NPV = +219.1\text{ k USD} > 0$, the water recycling investment is economically attractive and yields a return exceeding the $9\%$ MARR.