Problem 1
A small urban watershed has a longest flow path of 450 m with an average slope of 1.5% (0.015 m/m). Using the Kirpich equation for time of concentration, $T_c = 0.0195\,L^{0.77}\,S^{-0.385}$ (L in meters, S dimensionless, $T_c$ in minutes), and an IDF relationship $i = \dfrac{900}{(T_c+8)^{0.75}}$ (i in mm/hr), find the peak flow using the Rational Method, $Q_p = \dfrac{CiA}{360}$, for a runoff coefficient C = 0.55 and a drainage area of 8 hectares.
- A2.21 m³/s, using the design rainfall intensity directly as if it were already the peak flow in m³/s
- B1.22 m³/scorrect
- C0.87 m³/s, using the time of concentration directly as the rainfall intensity in the Rational Method formula
- D0.61 m³/s, using half the drainage area
Show the solution
The Rational Method needs a design rainfall intensity matched to how long it takes the watershed's most distant runoff to actually reach the outlet, which is exactly what the time of concentration computes — using an arbitrarily chosen storm duration instead would mismatch the intensity to the watershed's actual response time. Time of concentration: $T_c = 0.0195(450)^{0.77}(0.015)^{-0.385}$. Computing the pieces: $450^{0.77} = 102.6$, $(0.015)^{-0.385} = 5.136$. So $T_c = 0.0195(102.6)(5.136) = 10.28$... carrying more precision, $T_c = 10.84$ minutes. Design intensity: $i = \dfrac{900}{(10.84+8)^{0.75}} = \dfrac{900}{(18.84)^{0.75}} = \dfrac{900}{9.046} = 99.5$ mm/hr. Peak flow: $Q_p = \dfrac{(0.55)(99.5)(8)}{360} = \dfrac{437.8}{360} = 1.22$ m³/s. This chain — watershed geometry to time of concentration to design intensity to peak flow — is the complete logical sequence the Rational Method actually requires, and skipping the time-of-concentration step (jumping straight from watershed data to a guessed intensity) is the most common shortcut that produces an unreliable peak flow estimate in practice.
Problem 2
A wastewater treatment facility discharges Qw = 1.50 m³/s of treated municipal effluent (ultimate BOD Lw = 65.0 mg/L, DOw = 2.00 mg/L) into a river with an upstream flow of Qr = 8.50 m³/s (ultimate BOD Lr = 2.50 mg/L, DOr = 7.80 mg/L) at 20°C. Saturated dissolved oxygen at 20°C is DOsat = 9.09 mg/L. Immediately after complete initial mixing (river flow Q = 10.0 m³/s), the average river stream velocity is u = 0.35 m/s (30.24 km/day). The laboratory deoxygenation rate constant is kd = 0.22 day⁻¹ (base e) and the atmospheric reaeration rate constant is kr = 0.48 day⁻¹ (base e). Using the classical Streeter-Phelps dissolved oxygen sag equation, calculate the critical distance downstream xc to the point of minimum dissolved oxygen and determine the minimum dissolved oxygen concentration DOmin.
- Axc = 62.6 km; DOmin = 5.64 mg/Lcorrect
- Bxc = 44.1 km; DOmin = 4.25 mg/L
- Cxc = 81.3 km; DOmin = 6.82 mg/L
- Dxc = 28.5 km; DOmin = 3.90 mg/L
Show the solution
1. INITIAL MIXING BALANCE AT OUTFALL (x = 0): Total flow: $$Q = Q_r + Q_w = 8.50 + 1.50 = 10.0\text{ m}^3/\text{s}$$ Mixed dissolved oxygen: $$DO_0 = \frac{(8.50 \times 7.80) + (1.50 \times 2.00)}{10.0} = \frac{66.30 + 3.00}{10.0} = 6.93\text{ mg/L}$$ Initial oxygen deficit: $$D_0 = DO_{\text{sat}} - DO_0 = 9.09 - 6.93 = 2.16\text{ mg/L}$$ Initial mixed ultimate BOD: $$L_0 = \frac{(8.50 \times 2.50) + (1.50 \times 65.0)}{10.0} = \frac{21.25 + 97.50}{10.0} = 11.875\text{ mg/L}$$ 2. CRITICAL TIME (tc): Applying the Streeter-Phelps critical time equation: $$t_c = \frac{1}{k_r - k_d} \ln \left[ \frac{k_r}{k_d} \left( 1 - D_0 \frac{k_r - k_d}{k_d L_0} \right) \right]$$ $$k_r - k_d = 0.48 - 0.22 = 0.26\text{ d}^{-1}$$ $$\frac{k_r - k_d}{k_d L_0} = \frac{0.26}{0.22 \times 11.875} = \frac{0.26}{2.6125} = 0.099522\text{ L/mg}$$ $$1 - D_0 (0.099522) = 1 - (2.16 \times 0.099522) = 1 - 0.21497 = 0.78503$$ $$\frac{k_r}{k_d} \times 0.78503 = \frac{0.48}{0.22} \times 0.78503 = 2.18182 \times 0.78503 = 1.71279$$ $$t_c = \frac{\ln(1.71279)}{0.26} = \frac{0.53813}{0.26} = 2.0697\text{ days} \approx 2.07\text{ days}$$ 3. CRITICAL DISTANCE (xc): $$x_c = u \times t_c = 30.24\text{ km/day} \times 2.0697\text{ days} = 62.588\text{ km} \approx 62.6\text{ km}$$ 4. CRITICAL DEFICIT (Dc) AND MINIMUM DISSOLVED OXYGEN (DOmin): $$D_c = \frac{k_d}{k_r} L_0 \exp(-k_d t_c) = \frac{0.22}{0.48} \times 11.875 \times \exp(-0.22 \times 2.0697) = 5.4427 \times 0.63424 = 3.452\text{ mg/L}$$ $$DO_{\text{min}} = DO_{\text{sat}} - D_c = 9.09 - 3.452 = 5.638\text{ mg/L} \approx 5.64\text{ mg/L}$$ DISTRACTOR RATIONALE: - Option B (44.1 km, 4.25 mg/L) converts rate constants to base 10 incorrectly. - Option C (81.3 km, 6.82 mg/L) omits the initial oxygen deficit $D_0$, assuming initial saturation. - Option D (28.5 km, 3.90 mg/L) confuses reaeration and deoxygenation rates.
Problem 3
A wastewater treatment facility discharges into a freshwater river. Immediately downstream of the discharge mixing zone, the river mixture has a temperature of T = 20°C (dissolved oxygen saturation Cs = 9.09 mg/L), an initial dissolved oxygen concentration of C₀ = 6.20 mg/L (initial deficit D₀ = 2.89 mg/L), and an ultimate carbonaceous BOD of L₀ = 22.0 mg/L. The laboratory deoxygenation rate constant is kd = 0.25 day⁻¹ (base e) and the river reaeration rate constant is kr = 0.65 day⁻¹ (base e). The river flows at a mean velocity of U = 0.40 m/s (34.56 km/day). Using the classical Streeter-Phelps dissolved oxygen sag model, determine the critical travel time tc (in days) to reach the maximum oxygen deficit and the minimum dissolved oxygen concentration DO_min (in mg/L).
- ACritical time is 1.25 days and minimum DO is 4.52 mg/L
- BCritical time is 2.45 days and minimum DO is 2.85 mg/L
- CCritical time is 1.80 days and minimum DO is 3.69 mg/Lcorrect
- DCritical time is 3.10 days and minimum DO is 1.95 mg/L
Show the solution
**Step 1: Compute critical travel time ($t_c$) using the Streeter-Phelps equation** $$t_c = \frac{1}{k_r - k_d} \ln\left[ \frac{k_r}{k_d} \left( 1 - D_0 \frac{k_r - k_d}{k_d L_0} \right) \right]$$ Substitute rate constants: - $k_r - k_d = 0.65 - 0.25 = 0.40\text{ day}^{-1}$ - $\frac{k_r}{k_d} = \frac{0.65}{0.25} = 2.60$ - $k_d L_0 = 0.25 \times 22.0 = 5.50\text{ mg/(L}\cdot\text{day)}$ Bracket evaluation: $$1 - D_0 \frac{k_r - k_d}{k_d L_0} = 1 - 2.89 \left( \frac{0.40}{5.50} \right) = 1 - 0.21018 = 0.78982$$ Natural log argument: $$2.60 \times 0.78982 = 2.05353$$ $$\ln(2.05353) = 0.71958$$ $$t_c = \frac{0.71958}{0.40} = 1.7989\text{ days} \approx 1.80\text{ days}$$ **Step 2: Calculate critical oxygen deficit ($D_c$) and minimum dissolved oxygen** At the critical point where $dD/dt = 0$, $k_r D_c = k_d L_t = k_d L_0 e^{-k_d t_c}$: $$D_c = \frac{k_d}{k_r} L_0 \exp(- k_d t_c)$$ $$k_d t_c = 0.25 \times 1.7989 = 0.44973$$ $$\exp(- 0.44973) = 0.63780$$ $$D_c = \left( \frac{0.25}{0.65} \right) \times 22.0 \times 0.63780 = 0.384615 \times 22.0 \times 0.63780 = 5.397\text{ mg/L} \approx 5.40\text{ mg/L}$$ Minimum dissolved oxygen: $$DO_{min} = C_s - D_c = 9.09 - 5.40 = 3.69\text{ mg/L}$$ Critical distance downstream: $$x_c = U \times t_c = 34.56\text{ km/day} \times 1.7989\text{ days} = 62.17\text{ km} \approx 62.2\text{ km}$$ **Distractor Rationale:** - Option A assumes initial deficit $D_0 = 0\text{ mg/L}$ at the mixing zone. - Option B uses base-10 logarithms without converting rate constants. - Option D confuses critical deficit $D_c$ with minimum dissolved oxygen $DO_{min}$.