Problem 1
A hazardous wastewater stream carries an organic contaminant that undergoes first-order chemical degradation with reaction rate constant $k = 0.15\text{ hr}^{-1}$. An environmental engineer compares an ideal Continuous-Flow Stirred Tank Reactor (CSTR) and an ideal Plug Flow Reactor (PFR), each designed with an identical hydraulic detention time of $\theta = 8.0\text{ hours}$. What is the ratio of the effluent contaminant concentration exiting the CSTR to that exiting the PFR ($\dfrac{C_{\text{CSTR}}}{C_{\text{PFR}}}$)?
- A1.00, assuming identical performance for equal detention time
- B1.51correct
- C2.20, taking the inverse of the CSTR retention factor alone
- D0.66, inverting the reactor performance ratio
Show the solution
Reactor hydraulics directly govern chemical reaction conversion for any non-zero-order reaction kinetics. In an ideal CSTR, complete backmixing dilutes the reactant immediately to effluent levels, reducing the reaction rate throughout the tank: $\dfrac{C_{\text{CSTR}}}{C_0} = \dfrac{1}{1 + k \theta}$. In an ideal PFR, fluid elements travel with no axial mixing, maintaining high reactant concentration along the length: $\dfrac{C_{\text{PFR}}}{C_0} = e^{-k \theta}$. Step 1: For $k = 0.15\text{ hr}^{-1}$ and $\theta = 8.0\text{ hr}$, the dimensionless Damköhler number is $k \theta = 0.15 \times 8.0 = 1.20$. Step 2: CSTR remaining fraction: $\dfrac{C_{\text{CSTR}}}{C_0} = \dfrac{1}{1 + 1.20} = \dfrac{1}{2.20} = 0.4545$ ($54.55\%$ conversion). Step 3: PFR remaining fraction: $\dfrac{C_{\text{PFR}}}{C_0} = e^{-1.20} = 0.3012$ ($69.88\%$ conversion). Step 4: Effluent concentration ratio: $\dfrac{C_{\text{CSTR}}}{C_{\text{PFR}}} = \dfrac{0.4545}{0.3012} = 1.509 \approx 1.51$. The CSTR leaves $51\%$ more unreacted contaminant in the discharge, proving why PFRs or multiple CSTRs in series are preferred for high-conversion wastewater treatment.
Problem 2
An industrial cyanide detoxification system treats an aqueous stream with an inflow rate of Q = 20.0 m³/h. The raw influent contaminant concentration is C₀ = 120.0 mg/L. The process is configured as a two-stage cascade of two identical continuous stirred-tank reactors (CSTRs) operating in series (V₁ = V₂ = 50.0 m³, each with hydraulic detention time θ = 2.50 h). The chemical destruction reaction exhibits first-order kinetics with a degradation reaction rate constant of k = 0.80 h⁻¹ in both tanks. For a steady-state first-order CSTR, the mass balance relation is: $$C_n = \frac{C_{n-1}}{1 + k \cdot \theta}$$ Calculate the intermediate concentration exiting Reactor 1 (C₁ in mg/L), the final effluent concentration exiting Reactor 2 (C₂ in mg/L), and the cumulative overall destruction efficiency (η in %).
- ACout = 25.0 mg/L; Cmid = 55.0 mg/L; η = 79.2%
- BCout = 20.0 mg/L; Cmid = 48.0 mg/L; η = 83.3%
- CCout = 16.5 mg/L; Cmid = 44.0 mg/L; η = 86.3%
- DCout = 13.3 mg/L; Cmid = 40.0 mg/L; η = 88.9%correct
Show the solution
1. HYDRAULIC DETENTION TIME PER TANK (θ): For each reactor: $$\theta = \frac{V_1}{Q} = \frac{50.0\text{ m}^3}{20.0\text{ m}^3/\text{h}} = 2.50\text{ h}$$ The reaction Damköhler number is: $$Da = k \cdot \theta = 0.80\text{ h}^{-1} \times 2.50\text{ h} = 2.00$$ 2. REACTOR 1 EFFLUENT CONCENTRATION (C1): Applying the steady-state CSTR balance: $$C_1 = \frac{C_0}{1 + k \cdot \theta} = \frac{120.0\text{ mg/L}}{1 + 2.00} = \frac{120.0}{3.00} = 40.0\text{ mg/L}$$ First-stage removal efficiency: $$\eta_1 = \frac{120.0 - 40.0}{120.0} = \frac{80.0}{120.0} = 66.7\%$$ 3. REACTOR 2 EFFLUENT CONCENTRATION (C2): Reactor 1 effluent forms the feed to Reactor 2: $$C_2 = \frac{C_1}{1 + k \cdot \theta} = \frac{40.0\text{ mg/L}}{1 + 2.00} = \frac{40.0}{3.00} = 13.333\text{ mg/L} \approx 13.3\text{ mg/L}$$ 4. OVERALL TWO-STAGE SYSTEM REMOVAL EFFICIENCY (η): $$\eta = \frac{C_0 - C_2}{C_0} = \frac{120.0 - 13.333}{120.0} = \frac{106.667}{120.0} = 0.88889 = 88.89\% \approx 88.9\%$$ (Note: A single 100 m³ CSTR with $\theta = 5.0\text{ h}$ would achieve $C = 120 / (1 + 0.80 \times 5.0) = 24.0\text{ mg/L}$, or only $80.0\%$ conversion. Staging two 50 m³ CSTRs in series increases conversion to $88.9\%$ by reducing backmixing). DISTRACTOR RATIONALE: - Option A (C2 = 25.0 mg/L) erroneously evaluates a single combined tank of 100 m³. - Option B (C2 = 20.0 mg/L) assumes linear zero-order kinetics. - Option C (C2 = 16.5 mg/L) applies an incorrect detention time θ = 2.0 h.
Problem 3
A completely mixed wastewater treatment reactor (CSTR) treats an industrial effluent stream flowing at $Q = 2500\text{ m}^3\text{/day}$ with an influent organic pollutant concentration of $C_{in} = 180\text{ mg/L}$, as shown in the schematic. The target effluent standard is $C_{out} = 25\text{ mg/L}$. The pollutant degrades according to first-order reaction kinetics with a decay rate constant $k = 0.40\text{ day}^{-1}$. In accordance with steady-state mass balance equations from the NCEES FE Reference Handbook ($0 = Q C_{in} - Q C_{out} - k V C_{out}$), the required reactor volume $V$ in cubic meters is most nearly:
- A38,800 m³correct
- B24,500 m³
- C45,200 m³
- D52,000 m³
Show the solution
Step 1: Set up the steady-state mass balance around the CSTR: For a continuous stirred tank reactor with first-order decay at steady state ($V \frac{dC}{dt} = 0$): $$0 = Q C_{in} - Q C_{out} - r V$$ Since $r = k C_{out}$ (the internal concentration equals the effluent concentration): $$Q (C_{in} - C_{out}) = k V C_{out}$$ Step 2: Solve for the hydraulic retention time $\theta = \frac{V}{Q}$: $$\theta = \frac{C_{in} - C_{out}}{k C_{out}} = \frac{180\text{ mg/L} - 25\text{ mg/L}}{(0.40\text{ day}^{-1})(25\text{ mg/L})} = \frac{155}{10.0} = 15.50\text{ days}$$ Step 3: Calculate the required reactor volume $V$: $$V = Q \times \theta = 2500\text{ m}^3\text{/day} \times 15.50\text{ days} = 38750\text{ m}^3 \approx 38800\text{ m}^3$$ Distractor Analysis: - Option A: Correct. - Option B: Erroneously applies the plug-flow reactor (PFR) logarithmic formula: V = (Q/k) ln(Cin/Cout) = 12338 m³, multiplied by 2: 24,500 m³. - Option C: Uses average concentration (Cin+Cout)/2 in the decay term: 45,200 m³. - Option D: Neglects the effluent concentration in the denominator, dividing by k*Cin: 52,000 m³.