Problem 1
An engineer deposits 5,000 USD today into an account earning 6% annual interest, compounded annually. What will the account be worth after 10 years, in dollars? Enter a number only, rounded to the nearest dollar.
Show the solution
A single present sum growing at compound interest follows the standard future-value relation: F = P (1 + i)^n Substitute: F = 5000 (1.06)^10 (1.06)^10 = 1.790847... F = 5000 (1.790847) = 8954.24 Rounded to the nearest dollar, F = 8,954 USD. A small range is accepted because (1.06)^10 is an irrational-looking decimal that different numbers of carried digits round slightly differently -- someone using a financial factor table (F/P, 6%, 10) might read 1.7908 instead of the fuller 1.790847, landing a dollar or two away, which is a rounding artifact of the lookup table, not a wrong method. The broader point worth keeping: compound interest grows the principal, not just the original deposit -- by year 10 the account has earned interest on interest for nine consecutive years, which is why 5,000 USD very nearly becomes 8,954 USD rather than the 8,000 USD a simple-interest calculation (5000 + 5000(0.06)(10)) would give.
Problem 2
A manufacturing enterprise is performing capital budgeting and economic comparisons among mutually exclusive mechanical equipment investment projects. According to the engineering economics principles and decision criteria in the NCEES FE Reference Handbook, which TWO of the following statements are mathematically and methodologically correct?
- AA proposed project alternative is economically acceptable if and only if its Net Present Worth (NPW) evaluated at the Minimum Attractive Rate of Return (MARR) is greater than or equal to zero ($NPW \ge 0$).
- BWhen comparing multiple mutually exclusive alternatives with equal service lives, selecting the alternative with the highest individual Internal Rate of Return (IRR) is guaranteed to maximize total net present profit.
- CWhen comparing mutually exclusive alternatives with unequal service lives using the Present Worth method, the analysis must evaluate alternatives over a common study period equal to the least common multiple (LCM) of their service lives, or evaluate Equivalent Uniform Annual Worth (EUAW) over one cycle.
- DThe conventional Benefit-Cost ratio criterion defines an alternative as acceptable whenever the ratio $(B - C)/I$ is strictly greater than zero, where $B$ is benefits, $C$ is operating cost, and $I$ is initial capital investment.
Show the solution
From the NCEES FE Reference Handbook (Engineering Economics — Present Worth, Annual Worth, Rate of Return, and Benefit-Cost Analysis): 1) Statement A is CORRECT: An investment is economically justifiable if its Net Present Worth (NPW) discounted at the MARR ($i$) satisfies $NPW(i) \ge 0$, meaning the project recovers capital investment, covers operating disbursements, and earns a return at least equal to MARR. 2) Statement B is FALSE: Maximizing individual internal rate of return (IRR) can lead to erroneous decisions because it fails to consider the scale of investment. A smaller project with high IRR may generate far less total net dollar profit than a larger project with lower IRR that still exceeds MARR. To select among mutually exclusive alternatives using rate of return, incremental rate of return analysis ($\Delta IRR \ge MARR$) is required. 3) Statement C is CORRECT: The Present Worth method is valid only for comparisons across identical study periods; when useful lives differ, the least common multiple (LCM) of lives must be used with repeated cycles assumption, or the Equivalent Uniform Annual Worth (EUAW) method may be used across one cycle because annual worth is independent of cycle replication. 4) Statement D is FALSE: The conventional Benefit-Cost ratio is defined as $B/C = \frac{B - \text{Disbenefits}}{\text{CR} + \text{O\&M}}$, and an alternative is justified when $B/C \ge 1.0$ (not $> 0$). Therefore, statements A and C are the only two correct assertions.
Problem 3
A mechanical ventilation upgrade costs 60,000 USD at year 0 and provides net annual energy savings of 12,000 USD/year at the end of each year for a useful life of 8 years with zero salvage value. The company's MARR is $i = 8.0\%$ per year. In accordance with Capital Recovery and Present Worth relationships from the NCEES FE Reference Handbook ($(A/P, i, n) = \frac{i(1+i)^n}{(1+i)^n - 1}$), the Equivalent Uniform Annual Worth ($EUAW$, in USD/year) of the investment is most nearly:
- A820 USD/yr
- B1,560 USD/yrcorrect
- C2,450 USD/yr
- D3,120 USD/yr
Show the solution
Step 1: Calculate the Capital Recovery factor ($(A/P, 8\%, 8)$): $$(1 + i)^n = (1.080)^8 = 1.850930$$ $$(A/P, 8\%, 8) = \frac{0.080 \times 1.850930}{1.850930 - 1.000} = \frac{0.148074}{0.850930} = 0.174015$$ Step 2: Calculate the annual capital recovery cost of the initial expenditure ($CR$): $$CR = C_0 (A/P, 8\%, 8) = (60,000\text{ USD}) \times (0.174015) = 10,440.9\text{ USD/year}$$ Step 3: Calculate the Equivalent Uniform Annual Worth ($EUAW$): $$EUAW = A_{savings} - CR = 12,000\text{ USD/yr} - 10,440.9\text{ USD/yr} = +1,559.1\text{ USD/yr} = 1,560\text{ USD/yr}$$ Distractor Analysis: - Option A: Uses straight-line depreciation without compound interest. - Option B: Correct. - Option C: Uses 10 years useful life. - Option D: Ignores capital recovery cost and reports nominal net cash flow.