Problem 1
A chemical plant evaluates two heat recovery configurations for a distillation reboiler. System A requires an initial capital investment of 120,000 USD, has annual operating and maintenance expenses of 8,000 USD, a useful life of 6 years, and zero salvage value. System B requires an initial capital investment of 180,000 USD, has annual operating and maintenance expenses of 4,000 USD, a useful life of 10 years, and a salvage value of 20,000 USD. If the company Minimum Attractive Rate of Return (MARR) is 8% per year, the Equivalent Uniform Annual Cost (EUAC) of System A is most nearly:
- A28,400 USD
- B30,550 USD
- C33,960 USDcorrect
- D37,200 USD
Show the solution
Step 1: Determine the Capital Recovery factor $(A/P, i, n)$ for System A with $i = 8\%$ and $n = 6\text{ years}$: $$(A/P, 8\%, 6) = \dfrac{i(1+i)^n}{(1+i)^n - 1} = \dfrac{0.08(1.08)^6}{(1.08)^6 - 1} = \dfrac{0.08 \times 1.58687}{0.58687} = 0.21632$$ Step 2: Calculate the annualized capital cost of System A: $$A_{capital, A} = P_A \times (A/P, 8\%, 6) = 120,000\text{ USD} \times 0.21632 = 25,958\text{ USD/yr}$$ Step 3: Add annual operating and maintenance costs: $$EUAC_A = A_{capital, A} + O\&M_A = 25,958 + 8,000 = 33,958\text{ USD/yr} \approx 33,960\text{ USD}$$ Step 4: Compare with System B: $$(A/P, 8\%, 10) = 0.14903, \qquad (A/F, 8\%, 10) = 0.06903$$ $$EUAC_B = 180,000(0.14903) + 4,000 - 20,000(0.06903) = 26,825 + 4,000 - 1,381 = 29,444\text{ USD/yr}$$ System B is more cost-effective over its lifecycle ($EUAC_B < EUAC_A$). Distractor Analysis: - Option A (28,400 USD) calculates simple straight-line capital recovery without interest: 120,000 / 6 + 8,000 = 28,000 USD. - Option B (30,550 USD) uses an interest rate of 4% instead of 8%. - Option D (37,200 USD) adds interest as a lump sum ($120{,}000 \times 0.08 + 20{,}000 + 8{,}000\text{ USD}$).
Problem 2
A chemical process plant considers an automated catalyst injection system with an initial installed capital cost of $P_0 = 120{,}000\text{ USD}$, zero terminal salvage value, and a useful economic life of $n = 5\text{ years}$. The system generates an annual pre-tax operational cost savings of $A = 42{,}000\text{ USD/year}$. The capital asset is depreciated using 5-year straight-line depreciation ($D = 24{,}000\text{ USD/year}$). The corporate income tax rate is $t_c = 25.0\%$ and the after-tax minimum attractive rate of return is MARR $= 10.0\%$ (uniform series present worth factor $(P/A, 10\%, 5) = 3.7908$). The net present value ($NPV$, in USD) of the after-tax cash flows is most nearly:
- A11,500 USD
- B22,200 USDcorrect
- C35,400 USD
- D48{,}000 USD
Show the solution
Step 1: Calculate annual taxable income and after-tax net cash flow from the NCEES FE Reference Handbook: $$\text{Taxable Income} = A - D = 42{,}000\text{ USD} - 24{,}000\text{ USD} = 18{,}000\text{ USD}$$ $$\text{Taxes Paid} = t_c \times (A - D) = 0.250 \times 18{,}000\text{ USD} = 4,500\text{ USD}$$ $$\text{Net Income} = 18{,}000 - 4,500 = 13,500\text{ USD}$$ $$CF_{after-tax} = \text{Net Income} + D = 13,500\text{ USD} + 24{,}000\text{ USD} = 37,500\text{ USD/year}$$ (Alternatively: $CF = A(1 - t_c) + t_c D = 42{,}000(0.75) + 0.25(24{,}000) = 31,500 + 6{,}000 = 37,500\text{ USD/year}$). Step 2: Calculate the present worth of the annual after-tax cash inflows: $$PW_{inflow} = CF_{after-tax} \times (P/A, 10\%, 5) = (37,500\text{ USD/year}) \times (3.7908) = 142,155\text{ USD}$$ Step 3: Calculate the Net Present Value ($NPV$): $$NPV = PW_{inflow} - P_0 = 142,155\text{ USD} - 120{,}000\text{ USD} = +22,155\text{ USD} \approx +22,200\text{ USD}$$ Because $NPV > 0$, the automation investment is economically justified. Distractor Analysis: - Option A (11,500 USD): Ignores the depreciation tax shield ($t_c D = 6{,}000$). - Option B (22,200 USD): Correct. - Option C (35,400 USD): Evaluates pre-tax cash flow ($42{,}000 \times 3.7908 - 120{,}000 = 39,213$). - Option D (48{,}000 USD): Neglects discounting (simple undiscounted cash flow).
Problem 3
A waste heat recovery heat exchanger is evaluated for energy conservation in a chemical plant. The annualized installed capital cost is given by $C_{cap} = (8000.0\text{ USD/year}) \times A^{0.60}$, and the annual operating utility savings is $S_{op} = (2500.0\text{ USD/year}) \times A$, where $A$ is heat transfer area in $\text{m}^2$. For a proposed installation with area $A = 25.0\text{ m}^2$, the net annual economic benefit ($NB = S_{op} - C_{cap}$, in USD/year) is most nearly:
- A3,250 USD/year net benefit
- B7,311 USD/year net benefitcorrect
- C11,850 USD/year net benefit
- D18,400 USD/year net benefit
Show the solution
Step 1: Calculate the power-law capital recovery cost term for $A = 25.0\text{ m}^2$: $$A^{0.60} = (25.0)^{0.60} = (5^2)^{0.60} = 5^{1.20}$$ $$5^{1.20} = e^{1.20 \ln(5)} = e^{1.20 \times 1.60944} = e^{1.93132} = 6.89865$$ $$C_{cap} = (8000.0\text{ USD/year}) \times (6.89865) = 55,189.2\text{ USD/year}$$ Step 2: Calculate the annual energy utility savings ($S_{op}$): $$S_{op} = (2500.0\text{ USD/year}) \times (25.0) = 62,500.0\text{ USD/year}$$ Step 3: Compute the net annual economic benefit ($NB$): $$NB = S_{op} - C_{cap} = 62,500.0\text{ USD/year} - 55,189.2\text{ USD/year} = 7310.8\text{ USD/year} = 7311\text{ USD/year}$$ Distractor Analysis: - Option A: Uses $A^{0.80}$ scaling factor. - Option B: Correct. - Option C: Overestimates savings by neglecting capital recovery depreciation. - Option D: Uses linear capital cost scaling ($8000 \times 25 = 200,000$ amortized incorrectly).