A horizontal cylindrical chemical process vessel is designed according to ASME Boiler and Pressure Vessel Code, Section VIII, Division 1. The vessel has an inside diameter of $D = 2.40\text{ m}$ (inside radius $R = 1200\text{ mm}$) and operates at an internal design pressure of $P = 2.50\text{ MPa}$. The construction material is SA-516 Grade 70 carbon steel plate with a maximum allowable stress of $S = 138\text{ MPa}$ at the design temperature. Welded longitudinal seams undergo $100\%$ full radiographic examination ($E = 1.00$). If a corrosion allowance of $CA = 3.00\text{ mm}$ is specified, the minimum required shell thickness is most nearly:
- A19.5 mm
- B22.0 mm
- C25.0 mmcorrect
- D28.5 mm
Show the solution
Step 1: Identify the ASME Section VIII Div 1 formula for cylindrical shell thickness under internal pressure: $$t = \dfrac{P R}{S E - 0.6 P} + CA$$ Step 2: Substitute the design parameters: $$P = 2.50\text{ MPa}$$ $$R = 1200\text{ mm}$$ $$S = 138\text{ MPa}$$ $$E = 1.00$$ $$CA = 3.00\text{ mm}$$ Step 3: Calculate the nominal pressure-bearing thickness: $$P R = 2.50 \times 1200 = 3000\text{ MPa}\cdot\text{mm}$$ $$S E - 0.6 P = 138(1.00) - 0.6(2.50) = 138 - 1.50 = 136.5\text{ MPa}$$ $$t_{nominal} = \dfrac{3000}{136.5} = 21.978\text{ mm}$$ Step 4: Add the specified corrosion allowance: $$t_{min} = t_{nominal} + CA = 21.978 + 3.00 = 24.978\text{ mm} \approx 25.0\text{ mm}$$ Distractor Analysis: - Option A (19.5 mm) uses diameter instead of radius or an inflated allowable stress. - Option B (22.0 mm) calculates the pressure-bearing thickness correctly ($21.98\text{ mm}$) but forgets to add the $3.00\text{ mm}$ corrosion allowance. - Option D (28.5 mm) assumes an uninspected welded joint efficiency ($E = 0.85$ or $0.70$) instead of the full radiography $E = 1.00$ specified.