A feedback control system for a stirred chemical reactor is represented by the block diagram shown. The loop consists of a proportional controller $G_c(s) = K_c$, a pneumatic control valve $G_v(s) = \dfrac{1.50}{0.20s + 1}$, a reactor process $G_p(s) = \dfrac{4.00}{(2.00s + 1)(0.50s + 1)}$, and a feedback transmitter $H(s) = 0.250$. Using the Routh-Hurwitz stability criterion, the maximum controller gain $K_c$ for which the closed-loop system remains stable (the ultimate gain $K_{cu}$) is most nearly:
- A8.52
- B12.83correct
- C15.40
- D18.25
Show the solution
Step 1: Write the closed-loop characteristic equation $1 + G_c G_v G_p H = 0$: $$1 + K_c \left[\dfrac{1.50}{0.20s + 1}\right] \left[\dfrac{4.00}{(2.00s + 1)(0.50s + 1)}\right] (0.250) = 0$$ $$1 + \dfrac{1.50 \times 4.00 \times 0.250 K_c}{(0.20s + 1)(2.00s + 1)(0.50s + 1)} = 0$$ $$1 + \dfrac{1.50 K_c}{(0.20s + 1)(2.00s + 1)(0.50s + 1)} = 0$$ Step 2: Expand the denominator polynomial: $$(2.00s + 1)(0.50s + 1) = 1.00s^2 + 2.50s + 1$$ $$(1.00s^2 + 2.50s + 1)(0.20s + 1) = 0.20s^3 + 1.00s^2 + 0.50s^2 + 2.50s + 0.20s + 1$$ $$= 0.20s^3 + 1.50s^2 + 2.70s + 1$$ Step 3: Set up the characteristic polynomial: $$0.20s^3 + 1.50s^2 + 2.70s + (1 + 1.50 K_c) = 0$$ Step 4: Construct the Routh array: Row $s^3$: $a_3 = 0.20$, $a_1 = 2.70$ Row $s^2$: $a_2 = 1.50$, $a_0 = 1 + 1.50 K_c$ Row $s^1$ coefficient: $$b_1 = \dfrac{a_2 a_1 - a_3 a_0}{a_2} = \dfrac{1.50(2.70) - 0.20(1 + 1.50 K_c)}{1.50} > 0$$ $$4.05 - 0.20 - 0.30 K_c > 0 \implies 3.85 - 0.30 K_c > 0$$ $$K_c 0 \implies K_c > -0.67$. Thus, the maximum stable gain is $K_{cu} = 12.83$. Distractor Analysis: - Option A (8.52) neglects the sensor attenuation factor $H = 0.250$. - Option C (15.40) drops the $0.20$ term in the numerator of the Routh element: $4.05 / 0.30 = 13.5$ or miscalculates the expansion. - Option D (18.25) adds instead of subtracting in the Routh determinant.